L'Humanité in English
Translation of selective papers from the french daily newspaper l'Humanité
decorHome > Society > Certain beliefs now in vogue
 

EditorialWorldPoliticsEconomySocietyCultureScience & TechnologySportInternational Communist and Labor Press"Tribune libre"Comment and OpinionBlogsLinks
About USA, read also
decor Concerning the Attacks of 11 September 2001, Why Does America have Doubts? decorTough Times in Store for the Gorilla decorLehman Brothers goes belly up decorGeneral Motors Dumps its Workers by the Side of the Road. decorPolitical Science: The U.S. Falls to the Right decorObama Strengthens His Lead decor“Yes, American Capitalism Is In Crisis” decorDemocrats and Republicans Vote for Bush’s War Budget decorDemocracy and the Financial Bubble decorBush Vetoes Health Bill decorThe Credit Crisis: Result of a Neo-liberal, Imperialist Trajectory decorThe Voyage that Puts France Back in Atlantic Backwaters
About China, read also
decorHong Kong chaos: What’s it really all about?... decorVisit seen as boost to Sino-Vietnam ties decor"France in Common" in a World in Common and Socialist China decorChinese investors could fund Areva decorClimate. It is less talk and more action for China decorThe Tiananmen Legacy decorInternet and the difficulty of cross-referencing reliable media sources decor Internet et le difficile croisement de sources médiatiques fiables decorCounsel Zhang’s Lifelong Struggle For Justice... decorThe Nature of Contemporary Chinese Society and "Changing Social Classes" decorMao’s granddaughter a millionaire decorChina has triggered a salutary change in Africa
About Russia, read also
decor# France. What is next? decorAccording to Moscow, Damascus bombed a... decorHappy New Year 2016 decorAnd the Syrian People? decorFrance strikes Syria decorA Year of War, and Unity Recedes decorUkraine: War Sharpens Oligarchs’ Appetites decorThe Black Sea, a New Region of World Confrontation decorNATO: Thousands of U.S. Soldiers on Russian Border decorUkrainian Army Flees Debaltseve decorUkraine: Kremlin Calls For Truce to be Respected decorUkraine: And suddenly at midnight, the cannons fell silent
Society

ORIGINAL FRENCH ARTICLE: L’air du temps

by EDITORIAL PAR MAURICE ULRICH

Certain beliefs now in vogue

Translated Tuesday 19 August 2008, by Edward Lamb

The certitudes in vogue, these days, are very singular; spreading their deceiving truths, authentic lies and approximate evidences, like the wind spreads clouds and smoke screens. One could enumerate them, one by one, in pell-mell fashion. For example the Dalai Lama is holiness, wisdom and liberty all in one, like the Holy Trinity and anyone who doubts that is an adversary of Tibet. The Beijing Olympic Games are an occasion for China to demonstrate its power (which was not the case for other countries before), and to hide from the eyes of the world its violations of human rights. Anyone who watches television and remains oblivious to that is either a simpleton or an accomplice who should be called to order, which French Television (Channel 2) missed no occasion to re-emphasize throughout the Inauguration Ceremony. Elsewhere, Russia, as a fellow journalist wrote, yesterday, « has invaded an independent country, a friend and pro-Western ally »… Not to mention Bolivia, where an oligarchic, racist, extreme right wing opposition to Evo Morales, is qualified simply as « globalist »…

No one doubts that Russia’s riposte to Georgia’s aggression against South Ossetia was intended to serve as a very demonstrative warning for its neighbours who might be tempted to look towards Western horizons and to NATO. But, can we, without reflection, close our eyes to the fact that it was Georgia who sparked the crisis by attacking South Ossetia? Can we pretend not to know that Georgia could not have done so without the United States’ - imminently present in that part of the world, where their embassies are veritable military and reconnaissance bases – being aware of their plans? The geostrategic chess game that is being played in that region of the world, where oil reserves are at stake, among other interests, is not a low-budget western movie with the good guys on one side and the bad guys on the other. Georgia could not have doubted that Russia would retaliate. Who wanted that bomb to explode and for what reasons? It is only by asking those questions, by laying all the cards on the table that France and Europe can contribute to the urgent restoration of peace.

Is the Dalai Lama a saint? Perhaps, as an individual. Even though holiness is not what it used to be… But, we are already on the brink of an overdose. Evangelistic announcements of the coming of the Messiah, who is going to edify us with his "teachings". He is represented as the essence of Buddhism, he who is only the spiritual leader of a very small minority of that religion. Tibetan Buddhism is certainly very trendy in the West, but it only represents some 8 million disciples worldwide among the several 500 million Buddhists belonging to other sects. Does one still have the right, in the fatherland of Voltaire, to have some doubts about a religion which mingles the wheel of reincarnation with a plethora of heterogeneous divinities in those regions of the planet where, as Salman Rushdie wrote, “you can’t even get on a bus without sitting on a few hundred gods”. Having said that, is it as if one had condemned Tibet, surrendered it to Chinese oppression? Or is the truth of the matter somewhat more complicated? [1]

Nicolas Sarkozy went to the Inauguration Ceremony of the Olympic Games. He will not greet the Dalai Lama and is criticized, here and there, for his inconstancy. But, who is to blame, if not the French President himself, with his ostentatious declarations and cutting style. And now we have it that he will be sending his spouse, in his place, to meet with the Dalai Lama! It’s Sarko’s variety show, pure vaudeville.

Otherwise, what could be meant by such relations between the Republic and the religious sphere, instituted by the President? The Pope, the Church and now the Dalai Lama as spiritual guides? Catholic priests and Buddhist monks being confided with the defence of our values, against laymen and teachers?...

Yet, there is method in this madness, a general direction, a common denominator. It leans toward the emotional, irrational, binary and Manichaean reasoning. It denies the necessity of stepping back to examine the situation and to reflect upon it. We shall continue to do quite simply the contrary.

[1Considerable background and current perspective on the subject of Tibetan Buddhism and the independence movement is provided by the remarkable new book Histoire du Bouddhisme tibétain : La Compassion des Puissants, by the Belgian historian Elisabeth Martens, published in 2007 by l’Harmattan, 25,5 €. (Note added by HC, l’HumaniteInEnglish)


Follow site activity RSS 2.0 | Site Map | Translators’ zone | SPIP